Your Body Is Not Your Own  Most health advice is built on Stoic bones: own it, no excuses. Good counsel — but for a Christian, the first premise is off. Your body was never yours. Bill's before and after picture

Your Body Is Not Your Own

November 02, 2026•7 min read

I read a lot of health books in the years after I decided to stop being the man in that photograph.

You know the type. Discipline over motivation. Own your outcomes. Nobody is coming to save you. Most of them were good. Several of them helped me. And almost all of them, I eventually realized, were built on the same foundation — a foundation laid about two thousand years ago by the Stoics.

I kept reading, and I kept hitting the same wall. It took me an embarrassingly long time to find it, because the wall wasn’t in the advice. The advice was fine. The wall was underneath the advice, in a premise so basic that nobody in those books ever bothered to argue for it.

What the Stoics get right

Let me be fair here, because I’m not interested in knocking down a straw man.

The Stoics were right about a great deal. They taught that some things are within your control and most things are not, and that peace comes from knowing the difference. They taught that your response belongs to you even when your circumstances don’t. They taught that comfort is a poor guide and that character is built in the doing, not the feeling.

If you have ever dragged yourself out of bed at five in the morning for a workout you did not want, you have practiced Stoicism whether you have heard the word or not.

I believe in ownership. I believe in accountability. I believe you have real agency over your own life, and I will tell any client exactly that, usually within the first conversation. None of that is in question for me.

So the problem was never that the Stoics asked too much of me.

Where it breaks

The problem is what they thought my body was.

Epictetus — a former slave, a brilliant teacher, a man I genuinely admire — put it as bluntly as it can be put:

“You are a little soul carrying around a corpse.”

That line survives only because Marcus Aurelius wrote it down in his private notebook, quoting his teacher. Two of the most serious men who ever thought about how to live, and this is the view of the body they shared: the real you is in there somewhere, and this thing you’re hauling around is not it.

The Stoics weren’t cruel about it. They had a careful category for health. They called it a preferred indifferent — something you would naturally rather have than not have, something worth tending, but not a true good, and not essential to a life well lived. Take care of the body, by all means. Just don’t confuse it with yourself, and don’t be troubled when it fails, because it was never really yours to begin with.

Read that again and notice how close it comes.

It was never really yours to begin with.

They were right about that. They were right about it for entirely the wrong reason.

Not a corpse. A dwelling.

Here is the sentence that reorganized everything for me:

“Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit within you, whom you have from God? You are not your own, for you were bought with a price. So glorify God in your body.” — 1 Corinthians 6:19–20

Paul and Epictetus agree on the headline and disagree on absolutely everything else.

My body is not mine. Correct. But not because it’s an indifferent piece of equipment I’ll eventually set down. It’s not mine because it belongs to Someone else — and He has moved in.

It isn’t a corpse I’m carrying. It’s a dwelling I’m keeping.

It was created on purpose, for a purpose. I am not its owner. I’m its steward, and I am not doing that work alone — God and I live in here together. That is a different relationship entirely from the one the Stoics describe. You do not maintain a temple the way you maintain a rental car.

What changes when the premise changes

This is not a technicality. Change that one assumption and the whole structure moves.

The motivation changes. On the Stoic frame, I take care of my body to demonstrate discipline — the body is the proving ground, and virtue is the prize. On this frame, I take care of my body so I have the strength and the energy to do what I have been called to do. The body isn’t the test. It’s the instrument.

The standard changes. A proving ground invites you to grind yourself down to win. A temple asks something different, and sometimes something harder: rest, feeding, maintenance, attention over years. Nobody impresses anybody by maintaining a building well. You just do it, because it’s yours to keep.

Failure changes. This is the one that mattered most to me. On a performance frame, a bad week is evidence against your character. On a stewardship frame, a bad week is Tuesday — you own it, you repair it, you keep going, and the One you share the house with is not surprised and has not left. Ownership without condemnation is a genuinely different experience, and it is far more survivable over a decade.

And the loneliness changes. This is where the Stoic frame failed me most practically. The dichotomy of control is true as far as it goes, but taken as a whole philosophy of health it leaves you alone with your willpower, and willpower is a battery, not a wire. I did not actually change because I got tougher. I changed when I had a system and people.

What this is not

It is not an excuse. If anything, this is the more demanding view. “It’s just a preferred indifferent” is a far easier thing to tell yourself at 9 p.m. than “this is where the Holy Spirit lives.”

And it is not a claim that you have to share my theology to get healthy. You don’t. I have coached people across the whole spectrum of belief and I will keep doing it gladly. Good nutrition works whether or not you pray over it.

I spent years around a nutrition program before I ever framed any of this in terms of stewardship, and that program is how I lost ninety pounds and how I’ve kept it off for more than five years. I still use it. If nutrition is what you need and the faith conversation isn’t, that door is wide open and I am still standing in it.

What I’m building instead

But I kept noticing something in the people I talked with.

A lot of Christians are trying to care for their bodies with borrowed tools — good tools, sharp tools, shaped for a different hand. They have absorbed the ownership language, and they’re carrying the whole weight of it alone, and underneath it all they have a conviction the tools don’t account for: that this body was entrusted to them, and that they are answerable for how they keep it.

That gap is what Temple Builders exists to fill. A place where Christ followers can build alongside each other — encouraging, checking in, holding one another accountable — while we do the ordinary daily work of caring for the temple. Not a different set of exercises. The same work, on the right foundation, with company.

Nehemiah rebuilt the wall of Jerusalem in fifty-two days, and he did it by giving every family the section in front of their own house. Nobody built the wall. Everybody built their piece, next to someone building theirs.

That’s the idea. You have a section. You were not meant to build it alone, and you were never the owner of the ground it stands on.


Where to start: if you want to know what shape your section is actually in, take the free metabolic scan. It takes a few minutes and gives you something real to work from. www.templebuilderreset.com

Average weight loss on the Reset 5 & 1 Plan is 12 pounds. Clients are in weight loss, on average, for 12 weeks. I’m an independent Trilivy Coach.

Back to Blog